I drink a protein shake nearly every day. Whether it’s in the morning for a quick and easy breakfast or after my 5:30 workout to help my body rebuild and recover. Protein shakes are an easy and convenient way to get the nutrients you need without giving into the common pitfall of eating a bagel with cream cheese in the office lounge.
I first started taking Collagen because of the proposed health benefits. With health claims that support healthy glowing skin, less joint pain, and the same great benefits of protein, it seemed like collagen was the answer. Plus, it’s virtually tasteless, odorless, and dissolves with anything. (You can add a scoop to your coffee or your yogurt without even noticing it.)
But, the perpetuating benefits, seemed almost too good to be true. What was the real difference between collagen and my normal whey isolate protein powder? Was it really better, or was I giving in to the collagen hysteria? So here we are, with in-depth coverage of collagen protein vs. whey protein to see which is better after a workout.
What Is Collagen Protein?
Collagen is a type of protein that is naturally produced within the human body. Like so many other things, you can also get Collagen through supplements – you can add hydrolyzed collagen to your protein balls and almond milk latte for a quick and easy boost of protein.
Collagen makes up approximately 30% of the total protein in the human body. Collagen is a structural protein that can be found in the joints, ligaments, and tendons. It’s also found in the connective tissues of the human body, which promotes firm, hydrated, and supple skin.
What’s unique to Collagen unlike other proteins, is that Collagen contains a high concentration of four distinct amino acids, that often lack in the modern-day diet; glycine, proline, hydroxyproline, and arginine, which help promote protein synthesis, joint health, bone health, and wound healing.
RELATED ARTICLE The Complete Guide To Collagen
What Is Whey Protein?
Whey protein concentrate is known as the gold standard of protein powder. Whey is actually the liquid by-product of cheese manufacturing. When the casein and water are removed from this by-product, you are left with what’s better known as whey protein concentrate. Most whey protein concentrates are composed of 70-80% pure protein and contain over 50% lactose, with a higher content of fat and carbohydrates, as compared to whey protein isolate.
Several studies have shown that Whey protein has anabolic effects and can help improve post-workout recovery and performance.
Collagen Vs. Whey: Collagen Is Not A Complete Source Of Protein
So what gives? With all the amazing proclaimed health benefits of Collagen protein, it seems like a no-brainer right? Here’s the catch – Collagen is not a complete source of protein.
The term, complete protein, refers to a food's specific amino acid profile. A complete source of protein is a protein that contains all of the essential amino acids. There are 20 amino acids that are utilized for human growth and metabolism. Twelve of these amino acids are considered to be nonessential, meaning that they can be synthesized by your body and do not need to be acquired through your diet. The remaining nine amino acids (methionine, lysine, isoleucine, histidine, valine, tryptophan, threonine, phenylalanine, and leucine.) are essential and need to be consumed through dietary sources of protein.
Complete sources of protein, contain all nine of the essential amino acids. The absence of these essential amino acids will inhibit the ability of tissue growth and repair, therefore limiting your capacity to build and rebuild lean muscle mass. Collagen contains 8 of the 9 essential amino acids. Moreover, Collagen does not contain these 8 amino acids in an equally balanced ratio and contains higher concentrations of glycine, proline, and hydroxyproline.
RELATED ARTICLE What’s The Difference Between Incomplete Vs. Complete Proteins?
Is Collagen Better Than Whey, Whey Isolate, Or Casein Protein?
Whey, Whey Isolate, Whey Hydrolysate, and Casein all provide very high levels of essential and branched-chain amino acids the building blocks that help you build muscle and are considered a complete source of protein.
Besides the amino acid content though there are some significant differences between these types of proteins, especially in regards to your lifestyle. For example, if you can't do dairy, then protein such as whey or casein, which is derived from the milk from cows, won't work, meaning that Collagen would be a better choice for you.
RELATED ARTICLE Whey Protein Vs. Casein: Which One Is Better
But, if you're lactose intolerant then you could drink Whey Isolate and Whey Hydrolysate ( and collagen obviously, since it's not sourced from milk) since these two protein sources go through a cross-filtration process that removes any remaining lactose, carbohydrates, and fat.
RELATED ARTICLE Whey Protein Vs. Whey Protein Isolate: Which One Is Better
Should I Start Using Collagen Instead Of Whey Protein?
If you’re drinking your post-workout shake to build more gains in the gym, then using a complete source of protein such as whey or casein will be your best bet to build lean muscle mass and help with muscle recovery.
Collagen, however, is a great source of protein for an extra boost of protein that helps with connective tissue support, joint pain, and healthier glowing skin.
To be completely honest, it’s hard to choose one protein over the other. Collagen is a profound source of protein that boasts added health benefits that conventional protein just doesn’t have. And despite the shortcomings of not being a complete protein, you can add Collagen to other proteins, in order to make a complementary protein (two incomplete proteins eaten together, to make a complete protein).
Overall, I wouldn’t use Collagen as my post-workout protein shake. But, I would use it throughout the day and add it to my coffee, yogurt, oatmeal, pasta sauce, and baked goods, to get an added boost of protein, that helps with my complexion and joint health since it’s tasteless, and has specific amino acids that you don’t typically get in your diet.
Thinking about replacing your post-workout protein shake with Collagen?
SWOLVERINE is an endurance athlete and active lifestyle brand. Made for the elite athlete, and the strong-willed our products were designed to fuel your athletic performance. We perform when you perform.
We believe that everyone can optimize not only their athletic performance but their human potential. The way we believe we can optimize performance is through transparency, clinically effective doses, and clinically proven ingredients with evidence-based outcomes. We provide the nutrients you need to power your active lifestyle.